More Research

The numbers don’t make sense. Why did so many molestation and assault cases happen, to so many kids? 

One pattern is very clear, that most of the cases involve boys, either adolescent or post puberty. According to Robert MacLeish, a lawyer in the movie played by actor Billy Crudup, said that 90% of the 400 sexual assault victims he represented were boys. Some believe this is due to the amount of gay priests, that in priesthood there could be around 50% of them that are homosexual. Comparing that to the general population, there is less than 10% of people who identify as LGBTQ. 

Others believe that there are many more factors at play. For example, one reason could be stunted psychosexual development. Priests entering ministry at a young age sometimes stop their sexual thoughts and emotions, without further learning and change. This leads to them possibly acting out as an adolescent would, since many would be on the same level emotionally as kids aged 12-17.

Another reason is the frequency of contact between priests and young boys. When people think of sexual assault cases, they think lots of the time it has to do with females, which is true. Generally, parents are much more likely to be comfortable with a priest being alone with their son than with their daughter. This causes boys to be alone with priests way more often, paired with the fact that over time boys have been known to help out priests more than girls. There is certainly a male dominated culture in priesthood and that could play a role in this as well.

More explanation as to why priests seek out adolescent boys is because of their age. This is a confusing time for everyone. Hormones are all over the place, and many sexual thoughts are usually clouded. The power dynamic between a priest and a boy that age makes it so that it is easier to take someone at this vulnerable time and manipulate them. Since these boys won’t understand these things themselves, priests can often use this to their advantage to confuse them.

Lots of these assaults were done to kids from poorer places. In many families that come from poverty, religion is a big deal. When a priest starts giving attention to a poor boy, it means a lot to them, so they’ll probably do what they can to keep that attention coming. This also ties to the culture of deference in religion, where it is expected to obey higher ups’ needs.